BYU has been under the lights and played in some iconic games over the years. This weekend, the No. 8 Cougars are faced with arguably the biggest game in BYU history, a battle against No. 2 Notre Dame.
It's the first time two top-10 teams have played against each other at LaVell Edwards Stadium.
Over the past week, the stakes have been raised, as more national attention turns to Provo. For starters, ESPN’s "College GameDay" is coming to town for the second time ever. The last time BYU played in the marquee GameDay matchup against Texas Tech last season, the Cougars lost 29-7. The last time
"GameDay" came to Provo in 2009, the Cougars got blown out by TCU 38-7.
On top of that, BYU and Notre Dame were awarded the prime-time TV slot, 5:30 p.m. on ABC. Saturday’s game has a lot on the line for BYU outside of national media and viewership.
“Boy, this could do so many things for BYU and recruiting, for rankings (and) for positioning itself for the College Football Playoff,” said Dick Harmon, a Deseret News columnist who has covered BYU since 1978.
BYU has barely missed the College Football Playoff over the last two seasons. Notre Dame also missed out on the College Football Playoff last year and some believe these two teams were snubbed.
So, as the “Battle of the Snubbed” nears, it's fair to ask: is this the biggest game in BYU football history?
“I think this would probably rank No. 1 because of all that's at stake with these two programs,” said Harmon. “The money that's on the line, if they make it to the College Football Playoff, what it means to the Big 12 now that you're in a P4 program. This is probably the biggest one.”
Now, the game hasn’t happened yet, so it's hard to say whether it will go down in the history books as a monumental win or a devastating loss. However, compared to some of BYU’s other big-time matchups and showdowns, the hype is just as high, if not higher.
“Another big one would have been that Miami game,” said Harmon. “I put that at No. 2 because of what was at stake for Ty Detmer.”
BYU’s historic 1990 win over Miami, which was ranked No. 1 at the time and the defending national champions, is a game that most fans point to as one of the biggest. In that game, Miami traveled to Provo and was shocked 28-20 as Ty Detmer and the Cougars dismantled Miami through the air.
Detmer finished that game with over 400 passing yards and solidified himself as a Heisman Trophy contender, an award he won later that season.
That win over Miami was a big deal, but few games were bigger than the 1984 national championship game. BYU’s 24-17 win over Michigan was historic and launched BYU into national title glory. It is also the only season in which BYU has gone undefeated, a perfect 13-0.
For Harmon, that game will always be on his all-time list.
“The national championship game is always going to be in the top three, probably some would say No. 1,” he said. “But that was more of a voting popularity contest, BYU just happened to be in the right place at the right time.”
Back then there was no College Football Playoff Committee that determined BYU’s fate. Today is a very different story and situation.
The same is true with each of these games: the upcoming game against Notre Dame, the 1990 win over Miami and the national championship game in 1984. Each of these had different implications for BYU at the time. Winning a national championship propelled BYU’s program to the next level. Detmer’s win against Miami was key in him winning the Heisman and continuing BYU’s legacy as the quarterback factory.
This Saturday’s game will help determine how BYU is viewed moving forward, along with the Big 12 conference as a whole. Sophomore quarterback Bear Bachmeier is in the process of creating his own legacy as a Cougar and leading his team to a win over Notre Dame is an essential building block of that legacy.
So it's hard to argue which game was the “biggest game” in BYU history because they are all so different. But there is one thing that all of these games have in common.
Each of them has set up or will set up BYU to shock the college football world and prove that it belongs with the rest. BYU has been on the brink of modern-day success and a win over Notre Dame might give it the push it needs to move to a truly elite program.
Editor’s Note: For an opposing perspective on this topic, read this article (opens in a new tab)by The Observer, the student newspaper at the University of Notre Dame.