Skip to main content
Sports

Faith-filled football: What religion means to football powerhouses BYU, Notre Dame

A big part of the narrative going into Saturday’s matchup between Notre Dame and BYU is that both programs are faith-based, private universities.

People like to talk about it as a “Holy War” of sorts, calling it “Catholics vs. Mormons.” Of course, both teams have always represented something more than just football, and this game gives fans of BYU and Notre Dame an opportunity to reflect on the significance religion has played for both teams.

Joshua Matson is a professor of religion at BYU and he’s been a BYU fan for his entire life.

“Starting in the early '90s my grandpa started buying season tickets," he said.

Growing up in southern Idaho, he mentioned how his grandpa purchased those tickets with the intention of taking the grandkids to games with him. Each game day, they loaded up and drove down to Provo.

He said that so much of his childhood was shaped around football.

“We’d wake up, and we’d go to the games … we have so many good memories,” he said. “BYU football has been a huge part of my life from as far back as I can remember.”

When asked about how he sees BYU using athletics as a means of accomplishing its mission, specifically in assisting individuals in their quest for perfection and eternal life, he pulled up the mission statement given by the BYU athletic department.

“I’ve often heard people say, ‘BYU doesn’t have as many members of the church playing anymore.’ We saw it with Jake Retzlaff, and we see it now with Bear (Bachmeier),” Matson said. “Look at the mission, it's to promote the values. It’s not just about saying, ‘look at us’. But we’re saying that we hold up these values, and we share them with people of other faiths.”

He talked about how these values aren’t things that are exclusive only to members of The Church of Jesus Christ.

“But look,” he said, “There’s a successful football program that’s emphasizing the values of the university, and also the values of the Church. And those values are not mutually exclusive to somebody who’s not a member of the Church.”

In several of BYU’s games this season, fans have criticized Kalani Sitake’s decision not to run up the score or keep the starters in.

Matson talked about this as well. He said that while watching the Cougars’ game against Colorado State earlier this season, his 8-year-old son looked up at him during half time and said how he actually felt bad for the Rams. By the end of the game, his son was happy that CSU also had the opportunity to have some success.

“My son is as competitive as you’ll get out, but he recognizes that,” he said, referring to the value driven sportsmanship of Sitake and the BYU football team.

Matson also had stories to share about how BYU athletics accomplishes the Church’s goal to spread the gospel of Jesus Christ across the globe through missionary work.

“I was on Prince Edward Island in Canada,” he said, “I just sat down for dinner and I was wearing a BYU shirt. Somebody came up and asked, 'Are you from Brigham Young University?’”

He said that this type of interaction happens all of the time as he travels for work, and that they almost always end up having a conversation about BYU and what it stands for.

“When we come back to the mission statement of BYU athletics,” he said, “these are student-leaders athletes — influential student athlete leaders… We always hear this about missionary work, that the most important convert on a mission is the missionary. So isn’t that all the more true about athletics? That the most important convert is the athlete. Is this experience more fully converting them to the Gospel of Jesus Christ?”

He said that if that is the case, then BYU is fulfilling its mission? He quoted Mother Teresa, who said that God doesn’t care about statistics.

“So yeah, we might have millions of eyeballs, and maybe or maybe not those will lead to conversion,” he said. He added that if BYU athletics is being run in a way that lives up to the values of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, and if that’s truly in the hearts of every athlete, then it is a successful program.

Matson’s experience as a fan is his own, but the sentiments and passion he conveyed are certainly shared by millions of other BYU fans. As members of The Church of Jesus Christ from all over the country flock to away games, we hear commentators complimenting the Cougars’ traveling fan base. What they don’t mention on air is that the Church is a global one, and where BYU is a symbol of that Church, it finds support in every corner of the country.

Of course, BYU isn’t the only school with a faith-based mission.

Notre Dame has a long history of faith-fueled football.

In the early '20s, anti-catholic rhetoric in America was at a peak. In May of 1924, the Ku Klux Klan was gathering in South Bend, readying for a rally. A flood of Notre Dame students caught wind of the gathering, and decided they would put it to a stop.

According to an article written in Notre Dame Magazine, Notre Dame men would stop Klan members who were arriving, give them faulty directions and follow them down alleyways to confiscate their white robes.

Klan members persisted with their march, and brawls broke out. The students eventually chased the Klan members back to their local headquarters.

“The tense situation lasted for three days, culminating with the students lobbing potatoes and other missiles at a “fiery cross” — a wooden cross lit with red light bulbs — hanging from the group’s third-floor office window,” wrote Margaret Fosmoe in Notre Dame Magazine.

Photo by Margaret Folmoe; Images on display at the Indiana Historical Society

In the ensuing weeks, the Klan wielded its political influence in Indiana to spin the situation into a method of spreading anti-catholic propaganda throughout the area. Moreover, they seemed to still be seeking revenge for the occurrence.

Notre Dame was in need of a boost in the public eye, while still also standing up for themselves. Though the confrontation may have grown violent, it wasn’t one sided, and was geared towards a vile hate-group that was doing evil things.

The president of the university at the time was Father John O’Hara. He formulated a strategy to combat the negativity perpetrated by the Klan earlier that spring. The football team was prominent, and was already popular enough that many people paid attention to it. Jill Weiss Simins wrote that “Father O’Hara’s inspired strategy was to put the full weight of the university behind championing its successful football team and the respectable, upright, and modest team members.”

Father O’Hara worked hard to link catholicism with the football team, scheduling press events that matched with the football schedule, and giving the team medals of the saints to wear during games.

In 1923, an editorial from the New York Times gave a creative narrative that referred to the Notre Dame Football team. It referred to the team as  “a militant Catholic organization,” and that they “made cross-country raiding expeditions,” and had “shown their prowess on many battlefields.”

The editorial even added that “worst of all, they lately fought and decisively defeated a detachment of the United States Army.”

“Yet we have not heard of the Klansmen rising up to exterminate the Notre Dame Football team,” the editorial read, showing that the Football team could indeed be a means of combatting the Klan’s press work against the Catholics. This gave Father O’Hara the proof he needed to know that his efforts wouldn’t be wasted during his PR campaign in the fall of 1924.

Notre Dame went on to have an undefeated 1924 campaign, capped perfectly with a 27-10 win against Stanford in the Rose Bowl on Jan. 1, 1925. This marked Notre Dame's first ever national championship.

Later that year, the name that had only ever been used as an alias for the team became their permanent moniker, and a symbol of their faith-filled battle against hate — The Fighting Irish.

John Cavidini, professor of theology at Notre Dame, gave insight into the role football plays for Notre Dame and its fans: “Even though a university is about reason and the life of the mind, there is something higher than reason, namely, revelation, which is addressed to faith,” he said. “But reason is therefore not self-sufficient. Its horizon is expanded by faith in something it could not find on its own, but can explore once revealed.

“The football team is seen therefore as representing this commitment to a university that stands for something higher than itself, summed up in the phrase, and in this order, ‘God, Country, Notre Dame.’”

Both BYU and Notre Dame have missions that involve flooding the world with faith filled, and educated individuals. Through athletics, faith can be explored and perpetuated into the world. Through this particular game, fans everywhere can see the prominence of these two teams, which act as symbols of religious pride, and high moral values.