Nearly a week after President Donald Trump’s ban of certain news outlets — CNN, MS NOW and Politico — from the White House, their credentials were reinstated.
In the early morning of Thursday, Sept. 24, Judge Timothy J. Kelly of the U.S. District Court in Washington, who was appointed by President Trump in 2017, granted CNN, MS NOW and Politico a 14-day restraining order, meaning journalists previously banned by the President would immediately have their press credentials restored. As those journalists returned to the White House, the access certain journalists have is still being limited.
On Friday, Sept. 18, President Trump posted to Truth Social, the social media platform he owns, saying, “effective immediately,” CNN, MSNOW and Politico were banned from the White House “as a result of their constant ‘reporting’ FAKE NEWS!”
Journalists from those news outlets were denied access to the White House the following day, and by Monday morning, those outlets filed a lawsuit on the grounds that President Trump’s ban violated their First Amendment right due to viewpoint discrimination, as well as their Fifth Amendment right to due process.
“The President was expressly clear about his viewpoint-discriminatory motive for targeting CNN, MS NOW, and Politico,” the plaintiffs said within the lawsuit. “And equally clear that the ban was motivated by his disdain for reporting he considers ‘one-sided’ and ‘never good’ because it ‘diminish[es]’ him and his accomplishments.”
In their formal response, the Trump administration said that “access to the White House is a privilege — not a right.”
Once the hearing concluded on Wednesday, Sept. 23, Judge Kelly did not make a ruling from the bench, but rather took time to weigh the arguments of the plaintiffs and defendants.
Early Thursday morning, Judge Kelly decided to grant CNN, MS NOW and Politico a 14-day restraining order. He ordered that the defendants “shall immediately return, reinstate, and restore the White House ‘hard pass’ press credentials held by employees of CNN, MS NOW and POLITICO.”
According to Judge Kelly's ruling, “to obtain a temporary restraining order, a plaintiff must show ‘that he is likely to succeed on the merits, that he is likely to suffer irreparable harm in the absence of preliminary relief, that the balance of equities tips in his favor, and that an injunction is in the public interest.’"
“This is a high bar, but Plaintiffs have met it,” Judge Kelly said.
As journalists from CNN, MS NOW and Politico rejoined their colleagues on White House grounds Thursday, they continued to experience specific limitations to their press access.
So, now what? There are a few things to take away from these recent events.
At the core of the initial lawsuit in response to President Trump's ban was the argument that the news outlets' First Amendment rights had been violated.
"The First Amendment is a constitutional safeguard for all citizens," Scott Howell, former Utah senator and current CEO of the Howell Consulting Group, said. "The First Amendment doesn't promise that every news story will be right or that the press will always be fair, but what it does do is it protects the press's freedom to question those in power."
Howell continued, explaining that even though the press is not a formal branch of power, it is often considered the fourth estate, functioning as an independent watchdog for the people.
"Free press asks hard questions, they check official claims, and they bring really important facts into the light," Howell said.
Although the “fake news” rhetoric predates the current administration, it is a growing apprehension, and a shifting public understanding of journalism.
Joel Campbell, a retired journalist and BYU professor of communications, said that “an unfettered press is important for democracy.”
“If we don't have some ability to have the freedom to criticize or to do investigative articles that may show something negative about a presidency, then democracy is lost,” Campbell said. “We need that ability for someone to be a check and balance on the government.”
It is not unpatriotic to question and investigate, he said. If anything, those actions demonstrate a deep appreciation for the American people and democracy.
Howell said that he learned firsthand the significance of journalists throughout his years serving as a state senator.
"Sometimes I didn't like it and I made mistakes, but I'm glad they corrected me," Howell said. "At the end of the day, it made me a better person. It made me a better servant to the people."
"As Americans, we can disagree with a reporter; I can challenge their story and I can demand accuracy," Howell said. "But we must defend the press's right to work without government interference or punishment."
Journalists play a role in informing the public, and they do it as a team, even across different news outlets.
“I don’t think people realize that we really are a team out here and it doesn’t matter what outlet you work for,” Cami Mondeaux, a journalist for Deseret News in the D.C. Bureau, said. “We all like each other, we all support each other and we all help each other with the job every day.”
It is the independent press, as well as diversity of thought, that makes journalists so important, including those who work within the White House Mondeaux said.
Mondeaux explained that reporters are essentially representatives for the people because it is their responsibility to ask the questions the people want answers to, especially those reporting in the White House who are face-to-face with the leaders of the country "to say, 'I'm here representing who you're supposed to be serving.'"
"Are there bad apples in journalism? Yeah," Howell said. "But we can’t judge the whole by a few bad apples."
A free press has the responsibility to expose corruption, hyperbole, abuse and wrongdoing long before they take deeper root. That is the role of a journalist, said Howell.
“I think it is something that we do need to take seriously — when the most powerful office in the world is saying they don’t want people in because they don't want negative coverage,” Mondeaux said. “It’s something that should concern everybody and it’s something that we all should be vigilant for.”
“Regardless of party, other presidential administrations have done things to shield bad coverage of themselves,” Mondeaux said. While President Trump's ban is the most recent instance of "shielding bad coverage," it is not unique to him.
Mondeaux said that it is important for journalists to "continue calling out the administration who does that" and for journalists to support one another through those situations. Additionally, readers should expect more from journalists to make sure they continue asking the challenging questions.
The issue has brought up renewed attention to free speech and peacemaking in the journalist community.