Skip to main content
Metro

AI marketing saves time and money but risks consumer trust

Ai image collage from provo farmers market
Local businesses are increasingly using accessible AI technology to save time and money on marketing. AI-generated promotional signs for desserts and hummus were displayed at vendor booths at the Provo Farmers Market. (Lauren Capone)

Visitors at the Provo Farmers Market approached booths loaded with cookies, gelato and empanadas. Glancing at their signage reveals a flawless, hyper-realistic image of the food. While the tangible food in the booth is real, the marketing images are AI-generated — and consumers are noticing.

AI image generation is more accessible than ever, allowing businesses to create marketing content quickly and inexpensively. While many local vendors are utilizing this resource, consumers’ opinions differ regarding the authenticity, value and honesty of the images.

Swapping expensive and time-consuming photoshoots for quick, easy and unblemished AI-generated images seems like a no-brainer.

“It's cheap and it's easy and fast and I think that's why we're already seeing a lot of it,” Scott Church, a BYU media studies professor, said.

Generating AI images takes seconds and often costs nothing. That financial impact cannot be ignored across the industry; for example, short-form AI-generated video advertisements cost 85% to 95% less than traditional video production, also seeing twice the completion rates.

Robert Walz, a professor in the school of communications at BYU and AI enthusiast, has seen this shift himself. He explained how an advertisement production can cost a large company around $50,000, while he has created AI advertisements in 15 minutes for about $150.

“Is it as good? Probably not. Does it sell? Probably so... I don't think (people) really care about the quality. It's the message, the information,” Walz said.

However, as AI content floods the market, some creators and consumers are pushing back against the loss of personality.

“I could have AI do it for me, but even if it's half the time it is going to be a fourth of the quality,” Annie Atkinson, a local artist and student, said.

Using AI for marketing is undoubtedly more efficient. Yet, data shows consumers still have expectations of human creativity, authenticity and transparency.

A recent report by the Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) titled "The AI Ad Gap Widens" shows the differing perceptions of ad executives and consumers regarding AI-generated advertisements.

The data shows that younger generations (like Gen Z) are more likely to see AI-generated ads as “inauthentic” or “fake.” Comparing data from 2024 to 2026, consumers have become more opinionated about AI ads and their perceptions are increasingly negative.

ai-generated technology image
As artificial intelligence becomes increasingly accessible, businesses are weighing the budgeting and time benefits of AI against the value of human-made content. Some consumers have avoided businesses who use AI-generated content. (AI illustration generated by Lauren Capone)

So while local businesses are saving time and money generating AI images, some audiences are skeptical about this massive global innovation taking over their local bakery’s signage.

“I don't think you should use it when it comes to creative things,” Georgia Lamoreaux, a BYU student, said.

Lamoreaux said there are places where AI is appropriate to use, and places where it isn’t. She wants people to leave the creative tasks to humans, who she thinks can do a better job than AI.

“There is a sort of intuition I think that we have, at least right now, where we can feel the images that lack humanity, that lack the involvement of human models and actors,” Church said. “People at least right now can tell when it’s happening.”

Church said the lack of humanity in AI-generated marketing content feels different, and he frames the current AI model’s images as a downgrade from human-made, creative content.

Because consumers value this authenticity, many expect transparency when businesses do choose to use AI. The majority of consumers from an IAB study said the use of AI should be disclosed for 100% AI-generated ads, AI videos and AI images.

“I would want to know if something that I'm consuming has been generated by a computer,” Lamoreaux said.

While AI offers businesses remarkable efficiency for marketing, the data reveals the hyper-realistic, pristine images are actually driving some consumers away.

A global study conducted by Auros in October 2026 found that 44% of Americans say they go out of their way to do business with brands that do not use AI in their advertising.

As AI-generated ads become more popular and the ease of deferring work and creativity to AI continues, Church sees authentic, human-made content becoming more and more a “premium" option.

In the coming years, this human authenticity will likely become a luxury and a deliberate choice brands use to signal higher quality and genuine connection with consumers.

Atkinson noted the possibility of AI-generated content signaling to consumers a lack of professionalism and devotion from businesses.

“[AI content] gets rid of some of that trust that the customer has with the company, because if they don't have time to create an asset or to make an ad, then they don't have time to take care of the customer,” Atkinson said.

Atkinson said taking the easy way out with AI-generated advertisements and signage can hurt brands in the long run.

Now, it is up to businesses to decide if the time and money saved by an AI-generated image is worth the possible loss of customers’ trust, approval and money. It is up to consumers to decide if they care.